So I am dismayed that I cannot get Daughtry tickets, even though he is playing just around the corner. I am really a fangirl over his album. It hits me right where I like my music. But, in the absence of my alt rock fix, I went to the Philadelphia Orchestra to see a Beethoven piano concerto and Sheherazade with Barb last Tuesday, and then we went to Carmina Burana for the sleet storm, where we continued our discussion about what is wrong (and sometimes right) with classical music today. Both were huge works performed in large and elegant halls (Verizon Hall at the Kimmel is shaped like the inside of a cello and the sound is clear and true everywhere. The Academy of Music, made famous outside the city by the movie "Age of Innocence" is old and elegant and the sound pools at the top.) On Saturday I went to the Unitarian Church, where Mimi Stillman played all 8 of Bach's flute pieces.
As it happened, all the pieces were mesmerizing. But lately a lot of it hasn't been, so Barb and I were discussing the absence of passion in the performances of classical
People like music because it talks to them, it makes a connection across a divide that language can't cross. Audiences will accept a lot of different messages, messages for the heart and also messages for the head, sentimental messages and also bitter and desperate messages, and cool messages. Even ironic messages. But if the music is not a communication event, if the performance looks down on the composer's message, if it does not engage the audience in its message, people will not come to hear it because the reason to show up--a community in dialogue with itself that includes the audience as an active participant--is gone. And when that is gone, so are you.